Cities undoubtedly play a crucial part in efforts to mitigate climate change. Many urban areas worldwide have pledged to pursue sustainability shifts by adopting environmentally friendly approaches. In recent years, Europe has seen a notable increase in smart city initiatives and progress toward building more sustainable urban environments. Currently, the idea of Positive Energy Districts (PEDs) is motivating districts and municipalities to move away from conventional practices and strive for greater carbon neutrality. This article examines five municipalities—Maia, Reykjavik, Kifissia, Kladno, and Lviv—that are participating in an active Horizon 2020 initiative. The main goal is to explore how these cities identified and chose the 10 solutions they plan to replicate. Data were gathered via conversations, interviews, and the replication roadmaps prepared by each city. It should be emphasized that every city faces unique conditions regarding political backing, funding availability, technical capabilities, and stakeholder engagement—circumstances that apply universally when introducing innovative, efficient measures. Municipalities throughout Europe and other regions may encounter comparable challenges, so this article also presents the experiences of these five Fellow Cities as they advance toward PED implementation.